Torchlight II Review

Disregarding their subsidiary background, Runic Games has two things in common with Blizzard. One, neither company could perfect the launch of their respective action RPG, and two, their ardent fans know how to bring down servers. While Runic forwent always-online DRM for Torchlight II, meaning customers could actually try the campaign on launch day, the developers clearly overestimated the number of pre-orders. Runic’s website crashed hard, preventing eager consumers from creating an online account and testing Torchlight’s first venture into the multiplayer realm.

The developers had that issue sorted out within a day, at least, giving rabid gamers a chance to really dig into the meat of Torchlight II. Players build a character from one of four classes, each tailor fit to a general preference of ranged, melee, and magic warfare. The Embermage calls upon the arcane to inflict burns and poison ailments; the Outlander dual wields firearms and wands to slay enemies from a distance; Engineers imbue their weapons and armor with Ember (fire), buffing their offensive and defensive abilities; and the deranged Berserkers invoke beast magic to augment their swift melee capabilities.

The pet system returns from the original Torchlight, too. You may select a wolf, hawk, ferret, panther, or if you’re the boring type, a bulldog or cat. These loyal beasts aid in combat with their own set of spells and separate inventory. Fishing – a throwaway habit in most other RPGs – rewards players with random seafood to nourish their furry friends and transform them into other creatures – spiders, crabs, warbeasts, skeletons, jackals, etc. – capable of silencing, stunning, or poisoning enemies.

These companions do more than just fight. They give gamers the freedom to unload their loot without ever returning to town. Once burdened with unwanted goods, your pet will disembark to sell its inventory of shields, chainmail, and other armaments at the town merchant, or pick up the health and mana potions on your shopping list. Meanwhile, your combat buddy will be unable to bail you out of danger as it departs for several minutes.


While players do acquire class-specific loot, most weapons and armor can be equipped by any of the four archetypes.  


Money was never an issue because of my faithful jungle cat. Although Torchlight II color codes its loot variety in typical RPG hues, I still picked up common gear if only to immediately stash in my pet’s backpack for an eventual trip to the market. Even so, players never have enough bag space thanks to the mounds of equipment that pile high with each grave robbed, crate smashed, chest opened, and beast slain. Thankfully, you don’t need to click on each bag of gold to pick it up, and for comparison’s sake, Torchlight II does offer more on-screen riches than Diablo III.

Torchlight II also omits weapon durability. In Diablo III, death cost players 10% of their apparel’s endurance, forcing parties to put their questing on hold to portal home and repair their tarnished valuables. Without weapon degradation (a plus in my mind), there’s little to splurge on. Torchlight II contains unidentified items, which players must analyze using identity scrolls, but these pieces of parchment dropped more often than the mysterious gear. Besides the enchanters that bedazzled the Outlander's armor and firearms with passive effects, I saved a majority of my gold for my hero’s inevitable deaths.

The penalty for dying varies depending on where adventurers respawn. Respawning at the hub town costs nothing, but this may put players farther away from their objective unless they died next to a waypoint. Reviving in the exact spot where they perished requires a heftier sum – about a third of one’s gold. If gamers want to avoid the dragon that just roasted their character’s corpse, or that stone golem that flattened them into a pancake, a tenth of their monies buys a resurrection at the beginning of the dungeon.


You would not be the first to mistake these screenshots for Diablo III. 


It is important to note the Torchlight II’s difficulty. For action RPG pros, the game recommends starting on Veteran (one notch below Elite). But my inexperience with Torchlight convinced me to begin on Normal to better acquaint myself with skills that still punished my user errors, even if most boss fights deteriorated into wars of attrition and potion spamming. The gameplay does not scale to your character. Each area is labeled with a level range that the game makes perfectly clear before setting foot in. But whether or not players fall within that level spectrum, the encounters within those dungeons will test one’s hotkeys. Activating the Outlander’s Repulsion Hex against bosses immune to its knockback effects wastes precious mana, and destroying conjured minions instead of the summoner only prolongs the inevitable: being overwhelmed.

Torchlight II never cheats, however. Whereas Diablo III’s invulnerable, teleporting, mortar-throwing, vortex-casting champions felt like a curse purposely developed to ruin your day, your death falls on your shoulders here. Torchlight's champions do exhibit a potpourri of monster traits, though I never encountered invulnerable combinations, and completing every side quest available ensured I always met a location’s level range. While not randomly generated, Torchlight II’s swamps, deserts, and mountains could easily encompass three or four of Diablo III’s settings. Their size contributes to a greater sense of exploration, as some caves have no quests tied to them whatsoever. They merely exist to hold throngs of goblins, ghouls, spiders, manticores, or whatever mystical baddies Runic could think of, waiting for some brave explorer to cleanse them of their loot.

Your journey through these camps, gardens, and torture chambers is supposed to benefit mankind, except the story makes little sense. Some steampunk figure called the Alchemist, a playable class in Runic Games’ previous title, succumbed to the Heart of Ordrak’s corruption beneath the town of Torchlight. For reasons unknown, only you possess the mettle to stop the Alchemist’s infection of the world’s elemental spirits. At this point, the narrative's lore lost me, but with how much fun I was having firing Bramble Shots to ensnare teleporting enemies, invoking the Stone Pact to increase health regeneration, and throwing my ricocheting glaive to eliminate hostiles in droves, I was far too preoccupied to follow the dismissible plot.


These environments look much less aliased than Heroes of Ruin's


Torchlight II presents a substantial amount of content at a modest price point, even if Runic Games needs a patch for the skill trees. Torchlight II does a poor job of teaching players the values of each character’s two dozen abilities, and levels come fast. At the 15-hour mark, my hero reached level 50. All those skill points found themselves spent in three active casts – the lethal glaive throw, the knockback Repulsion Hex, and the rejuvenating Stone Pact – passive perks that buffed my Outlander’s damage while dual-wielding. You can reset the last three skill points if you can spare the cash, but if you can follow step-by-step instructions, Runic posted a helpful guide for generating a respec potion after altering a few game settings. As an otherwise damnable feature, I applaud the developers for acknowledging their own limitation and giving consumers a workaround necessary for besting Veteran and Elite difficulties.

Now, Diablo III gave developers an idea how to avoid the pitfalls of post-launch support. Blizzard wanted to make players unrivaled badasses. Their nerfing of abilities thought to be overpowered had the exact opposite effect. Runic Games has taken a very open-minded approach to Torchlight II. Featuring the full suite of Steam Workshop customization, players can modify or create new content however they see fit. From simple NPC clothing swaps, to spawning dozens of monsters with the console commands, to building one's very own dungeons, Runic’s tolerance for user-generated material adds one more tally to the merit column.

Mods may even be implemented in multiplayer sessions with five other players. The challenge increases exponentially with the addition of more people, and from the few hours I played, I never lost a connection despite the peer-to-peer servers. The game runs well on lower budget PCs too, even when swarms of demons start detonating in showers of gore.

With Torchlight II and Diablo III releasing just months apart, the two undoubtedly invite comparisons, but $40 remains the deciding factor between one or the other. Runic’s franchise shares many visual qualities with Blizzard’s trilogy, including typical fantasy settings and creatures that pop like bloody zits, but on a gameplay level, they could not be more different. Torchlight II’s take on Internet connectivity, play styles, pets, side quests, bosses, mod support, and multiplayer will drain hours from eager fans, even if the narrative is completely bonkers.

Publisher: Runic Games
Developer: Runic Games
Release Date: September 20, 2012
Number of Players: 1-6 (Campaign)
Platforms: PC (Reviewed), Mac 

Goldteddy's picture

Hah if i had to summaries Diablo 3 with one word it would be: Wow.

They turned Diablo into Wow with all the nerfing and stuff, and they killed the bloody story!


Torchlight 2 still uses the skill point system yea, But they reward you for putting more points into the same skill ala Diablo 2 abilities granting each other % benefits. Like my Engineer Flame Wrench getting a larger Area of effect once i hit the next Tier of the spell. But like you said because of how the skill point system works, you won't really put alot of points into skills above the first 3 to 4.

One more thing i like about the game is the fact that no matter who you picked as a class, you won't be punished by having less equipment than the other classes.

Josh Kowbel's picture


In one of my first drafts, I brought up the recent patch to Diablo III that effectively makes all the characters overpowered as Blizzard originally intended, but this was not meant to be a post-analysis of Diablo III's launch. 

I actually prefer Diablo III's system of skill unlocking, though. I'd much rather have all the abilities available to me so I can experiment with different combinations. I did cut out the mention of skill tiers too, as the review started to read more like a preview. 

Mango's picture

It should be noted that the respec potion is a console command which if used will put a red ! sign on your name in online servers telling other players you have used console commands which could lead you being kicked out of the game.

John Tarr's picture

I preordered Torchlight 2, but another multi-dozen hour RPG is a big commitment to dive into. Your review makes this game sound spectacular, especially in the many ways that Diablo 3 failed to capture my attention, like with more challenging, non-cheating difficulty scaling, I just need to commit a few days to the adventure.

Josh Kowbel's picture


I haven't used the respec potion myself, and I have yet to see that exclamation mark above a player's head. Perhaps people are more committed to their choices than the developers thought. 

@John Tarr:

Diablo III and Torchlight II both have their pros and cons. Honestly, I could not recommend one over the other, as these two action RPGS are my only experiences with the dungeon crawlers. You'd probably get right back into Diablo III after the latest patch, though, as characters are proper powerhouses now. 

Create New Account or Log in to comment